Black Memphis vs. Black Nashville

From Our Kind of People: Inside America’s Black Upper Class, by Lawrence Otis Graham (Harper, 2000), pp. 276-277:

I am still a devoted fan of Memphis because of my childhood memories and because of the progressive people—both black and white—who I know are working together today; but like its black elite, who were educated elsewhere, I feel it is a town trying to overcome great odds. The thriving downtown that it once had along Main Street—between Beale and Jefferson—was killed in the 1970s when the whites abandoned the increasingly black city, which now is only 44 percent white. There is not a department store within ten miles of City Hall. Big stores like Gerber’s, Lowenstein’s, and Bry’s are all gone now. The area surrounding the municipal buildings, courthouses, and county offices is littered with pawnshops, bail bondsmen, and vacant storefronts. What would have long ago been a well-developed Mississippi River waterfront in any other town is just now seeing walking paths, green grass, and trees. With the exception of a few tall buildings built by the city’s superior hospitals—Baptist and Methodist—and by First Tennessee Bank and Union Planters Bank, one gets the sense that no major company or industry calls Memphis its home. Federal Express is there—several miles out of downtown, near the airport, but the headquarters for Holiday Inn and Cook Industries left years ago.

Statue of B. B. King, Memphis Visitor CenterEven the city’s premier hotel, the Peabody—as plush as it is, by Memphis standards—seems a bit corny and anachronistic. Founded in 1869 and rebuilt in the 1920s, the imposing brick structure attracts tourists to its main lobby each morning for a ritual that began in the 1930s and continues today, seven days a week. At 11:00 A.M. sharp, an elevator door opens on the main floor, and marching in line across the carpeted floor are five trained ducks. Marching in unison to taped music that plays over the lobby speakers, the small ducks waddle toward a small, ornate fountain and pool in the middle of the floor. One by one, they hop up to the fountain and then dive into the pool. The routine is repeated in reverse at 5:00 each afternoon. Since the hotel had a policy of segregation thoughout my older relatives’ lives, it was not until we were teenagers that they permitted us to visit the building and view this amusing event.

“Memphis used to have the largest and most developed metropolitan area in Tennessee,” explained a black former city councilman who acknowledges that a fear of integration is what kept Memphis small and rather underdeveloped. “It can’t be blamed on the people who are in power today,” he says, “but those who were making decisions in the 1950s and 1960s created a problem between the races and within the corporate community that was hard to correct.”

The city’s black elite seem to be painfully aware of how much better their black counterparts are doing in Nashville—a city whose metropolitan area had once been less affluent, less respected, and less populated than that of Memphis. In fact, most of the Memphis black elite who had grown up in the city prior to the 1960s had to leave town and go to Nashville in order to get their education. Although the town had the small, all-black LeMoyne College since 1870, it lacked the truly elite black institutions that Nashville had: Fisk University and Meharry Medical College. The black Memphians also lacked Nashville’s Tennessee State University, a black public college that ran itself like an elite private school.

“Although I grew up in Memphis—a city that looked down on Nashville at the time,” explains a sixty-year-old physician who attended Fisk, “I always had the feeling that Nashville was going to catch up and then leave us behind—intellectually and racially. Memphis had no premier schools for whites or blacks, and Nashville had Vanderbilt for whites and these other top schools for us. White Memphians—and even some black Memphians—seemed to get more backward and more provincial as other cities outgrew us. So few blacks here were able to break out of the box and really gain national exposure the way that blacks in Nashville did.”


Filed under travel, U.S.

6 responses to “Black Memphis vs. Black Nashville

  1. Pat

    I too grew up in Memphis and was whisked away in eighth grade by a frightened rascist father. I moved back a few years ago and saw segregation and inherent racism (on both sides) like I have seen no where else in my 50+ years. Perhaps Memphis is doomed to suffer for the assassination of MLK Jr forever. While there are good people still in Memphis, they seem to be struggling against incredible odds to bring some fairness and open-mindedness to the city. I moved away again after three years; it is truly depressing.

    • Kat

      I understand Pat. I grew up in Nashville and my father taught at Tennessee State University. I didn’t visit Memphis until the late 1990’s when I went there for a “Wonders” exhibit at The Pyramid. My mother and I left early in the morning because we were going to make it a day trip and not spend the night. It was about 9:30 A.M. on a weekday morning when we arrived in Memphis. When we continued in on Summer then N. Parkway we could instantly tell that Memphis had seen much better times. You could tell by looking at the beautiful old bugalows and apartment buildings that they had once been cared for, but were now owned by people who didn’t care. It was sad because you could you could see the potential. We continued on through town and to the Pyramid. We saw men sitting along side of historical large red brick warehouses. These men were in rags and looked as though they were saddened by life. There weren’t just a few of them, but many. I have held this image of Memphis in my mind and to me it seems like a city whose time may have come and gone.

  2. Jamal Abdul-Aziz Craft

    Nashville consistantly ranks among the best cities for African-Americans in the country. When has anyone ranked Memphis as a top city for blacks or even whites. In the 1960 Memphis had 3 times more people than Nashville. Since that time Nash-ville has exploded in population and development to become the largest metropolitan area in Tenne-see and one of the leading areas in the South. Some are calling Nashville the next Atlanta. I dont know what Memphis problem is? Because in the South up until the 1960’s Memphis was one of the best cities for blacks. After Dr. King got killed there things stagnated to slow growth. In the last 20 years many Southern cities have developed and passed Memphis and blacks are moving not only to Atlanta and Nashville but to Charlotte, Raleigh, Orlando, Miami, Jacksonville, Dallas ,Houston , Birmingham and to Virginia. Memphis need a new leadership to focus on bringing in jobs , technology and a new vision to make it an appealing cityu for all people.

  3. Bj

    Memphis is good to me.. You can find whatever you want (good or bad if you look for it) focus on good Memphis and she will be good and blessed. Focus on the bad and be damned. It’s on how you see it Memphis is good to me

  4. OJ simpson

    TSU an elite private school? Are you kidding that shit hole sucks ass. It can’t get even get accredited in any thing but Ebonics studies. Only morons attend it as the entrance requirements show. A pulse is all that is needed to attend . Eliminated the parking problem from when it was a thriving UT nashville.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.